Published SourceCutting / Usage Record

Press Gazette Trump Dossier Article Shows Why BuzzFeed Was Wrong To Publish Unverified Raw Allegations

This archived screenshot preserves Dominic Ponsford’s Press Gazette comment piece “The ‘golden rule’ of journalistic ethics and why BuzzFeed was wrong to publish Trump dossier”, published after BuzzFeed released the unverified Trump dossier as a raw document. The item is significant because Ponsford argued that BuzzFeed should not have published serious allegations in full without proper analysis, verification or adequate right of reply, and that the basic ethical test was whether a journalist would be comfortable defending the same conduct in public or before a court. The screenshot matters in the wider CEN/BuzzFeed evidence chain because it shows a respected UK media editor criticising BuzzFeed’s judgment on a separate major story, underlining a wider pattern of publishing highly damaging allegations while relying on the defence that readers could assess the material for themselves. Ben Smith later accepted that publishing the dossier in that form had been a mistake, making this article relevant to the broader question of whether BuzzFeed’s confidence, speed and moral certainty sometimes ran ahead of proper journalistic discipline. Read alongside the CEN litigation material, this item helps document the gap between BuzzFeed’s claim to be exposing misinformation and its own willingness to publish material whose truth had not been properly established.

Source

Part of Central European News & Mike Leidig v BuzzFeed (US Second Circuit Libel Case) – Archived Web Screenshots

Europe Media newsX CIC Published 3 May 2026 at 13:59 Source: 16 July 2016

Tags

Press GazetteDominic PonsfordBuzzFeedBen SmithTrump dossierDonald Trumpjournalistic ethicsgolden ruleverificationright of replyraw documentsunverified allegationspublication standardsmedia laweditorial judgmentCENMike Leidigfake newslibel risksource evidencearchived web screenshotlibel case evidence

Rights & Licensing

Reference / Usage Record Only

Credit: newsX

These materials consist of screenshots of third-party web content preserved for evidential and archival purposes. They are provided for reference, research, and documentation only. No rights are granted to reuse or republish the underlying content, which may be subject to third-party copyright and other legal protections.

This is a usage record. It shows where material appeared or how it was used, rather than being an original source document itself. Usage records support tracking of publication history, attribution, republication, syndication and proof of use.

File SCREEN - The 'golden rule' of journalistic ethics and why Buzzfeed was wrong_ - [pressgazette.co.uk].pdf · 300.5 KB Download

This material was submitted by a member. Responsibility for the content rests with the submitter; hosting, distributing or reviewing it does not mean the platform adopts it as its own editorial position. Platform notice · File a complaint