Published SourceCutting / Usage Record

BuzzFeed Article By Ryan Broderick Choosing One Viral Narrative Over Another Without Original Proof

Screenshot of a BuzzFeed article titled “This Woman Is Wrongly Being Called A Sexual Predator After Her Private Photos Were Stolen”, used here not simply as a story about online reputational harm, but as an example of Ryan Broderick’s method of accepting one newspaper’s narrative over competing versions without clear original reporting or proof. The significance, as set out in the book, is that Broderick appears to have treated one account as authoritative because someone claimed the woman in the images looked like another person, without providing a name or proper evidence that it was actually her. The record matters because Broderick later became part of the BuzzFeed campaign against CEN’s foreign-news material, demanding explanations and presenting himself as an arbiter of verification, while his own work showed the same weakness: reliance on secondary narratives, thin identification claims and borrowed reporting rather than independently established facts. It is also useful in the wider BuzzFeed/CEN narrative because Broderick was later associated with plagiarism allegations, making this article relevant as an example of the same broader problem: using other people’s material or claims while applying a far harsher standard to others.

Source

Part of Central European News & Mike Leidig v BuzzFeed (US Second Circuit Libel Case) – Archived Web Screenshots

Europe Media newsX CIC Published 3 May 2026 at 13:59 Source: 16 July 2016

Tags

BuzzFeedRyan Broderickplagiarism allegationsborrowed reportingweak verificationsecondary narrativereputational harmstolen private photosfalse identificationonline accusationmedia ethicsBuzzFeed inconsistencyCEN backgroundselective standardssource checkingviral shamingdefamation contextnarrative double standard

Rights & Licensing

Reference / Usage Record Only

Credit: newsX

These materials consist of screenshots of third-party web content preserved for evidential and archival purposes. They are provided for reference, research, and documentation only. No rights are granted to reuse or republish the underlying content, which may be subject to third-party copyright and other legal protections.

This is a usage record. It shows where material appeared or how it was used, rather than being an original source document itself. Usage records support tracking of publication history, attribution, republication, syndication and proof of use.

File SCREEN - This Woman Is Wrongly Being Called A Sexual Predator After Her Priv.pdf · 1.2 MB Download

This material was submitted by a member. Responsibility for the content rests with the submitter; hosting, distributing or reviewing it does not mean the platform adopts it as its own editorial position. Platform notice · File a complaint