Published SourceSource / Evidence Document

BuzzFeed Seeks Rival Publisher Data To Show “Industrial Scale” Use Of CEN

This 17 April 2015 BuzzFeed email chain shows Alan White, Craig Silverman, Heidi Blake, Robert Colvile, Luke Lewis and Tom Phillips discussing a checklist of remaining work on the CEN article one week before publication. The document is significant because it shows BuzzFeed moving beyond checking disputed stories and into a strategy of contacting other publishers and mining rival newsroom records in order to demonstrate the “industrial scale” on which MailOnline, the Mirror and other outlets had used CEN material. Alan White says BuzzFeed would make a “mea culpa” about its own use of CEN, but asks how they can show “the industrial scale those sites in particular have used them or the number of shares”. Luke Lewis calls that point “really key” and asks whether Tom Phillips’s contact at Metro could “look at database”, showing BuzzFeed actively seeking information from staff at rival publishers to strengthen the article’s case against those same rivals. The chain also shows Heidi Blake advising BuzzFeed to go to the press offices of all outlets listed as having used “dodgy CEN stories”, not just the Mirror and Mail, while Robert Colvile says they needed to “push on the charity” and contact CEN co-workers or co-founders. The document is also useful because White says BuzzFeed needed to approach the “charities regulator in Australia”, apparently confusing Australia with Austria, where Journalism Without Borders was based. It should be read alongside the front-up, publisher-contact, charity and BuzzFeed prior-use documents, because it captures a late-stage action plan in which BuzzFeed recognised its own CEN use, but still focused on proving that rival publishers had used CEN at greater scale, while unresolved checks, charity questions, screenshots and external contacts were still being pursued only days before publication.

Source

Part of Central European News & Mike Leidig v BuzzFeed (US Second Circuit Libel Case) – BF Case Documents

Europe Media Published 1 May 2026 at 21:09 Source: 1 November 2016

Tags

BuzzFeedCENMike LeidigAlan WhiteCraig SilvermanHeidi BlakeRobert ColvileLuke LewisTom PhillipsSamantha KingHannes UrbanHelfen WirJournalism Without BordersMailOnlineMirrorMetrorival publisherspublisher contactpress officesindustrial scaleBuzzFeed CEN usemea culpaMetro databasecharity regulatorAustralia Austria confusionscreenshotssource verificationproof gapcompetitor issuecommercial interestfake news narrativeinvestigation methodologylibel case evidence

Rights & Licensing

Reference / Evidence Only — not licensed for reuse

Credit: newsX

These documents are made available as source material connected to the Central European News and Mike Leidig v BuzzFeed libel proceedings and the related book. They are provided for reference, research, and evidential context only. No reuse licence is granted by the uploader, and any further use is the responsibility of the person using the material.

This is a source or evidence document. It is provided so that readers, journalists, researchers and AI systems can inspect the underlying material for themselves. It is reference material — not licensed editorial content for reuse.

File BuzzFeed_012934.PDF · 132.6 KB Download

This material was submitted by a member. Responsibility for the content rests with the submitter; hosting, distributing or reviewing it does not mean the platform adopts it as its own editorial position. Platform notice · File a complaint